Borrowing from Jeff Foxworthy's "You might be a redneck" comedy style, I present "You might be a J..."
- If your desk has more post-it notes than work space- you might be a J.
- If you view the "Now Playing" list on your TiVo as a to-do list and race through the programs to watch and then delete them- you might be a J.
- If your purse/briefcase looks like a survival kit (Tide to-go pen, post-its, emergency contact info, band aids, neosporin, and everything else you might need to be prepared for)- you might be a J.
- If you have a Plan A, B, C, and D for every situation- you might be a J.
- If you drive to the location of your interview the day before (so you know the route perfectly and there won't be any surprises)- you might be a J.
- If Spring Cleaning in your house is planned out with Microsoft Project- you might be a J.
- If a family trip to Disney World takes as much planning as a typical wedding- you might be a J.
- If you automatically set your personal deadline one week (or more) earlier than the "real" deadline- you might be a J.
- If your friends can imitate the structure of your daily activities with eerie precision- you might be a J.
- If you sit down and read ALL instructions before beginning a an assembly project (and lay out each necessary tool, separate and count the parts, etc)- you might be a J.
- If you schedule free-time (but feel uncomfortable having free-time in the first place)- you might be a J.
- If the best gift you ever received was a Label-maker- you might be a J.

As someone who is at the extreme on the Judging preference (scoring 5 on ALL facets), I can relate to all of these comical representations of the judging preference!
I am typically quite fond of my J-ness! My coworkers rely on me, knowing that given a task, I will complete it ahead of schedule and without surprises. I dislike surprises, but when they occur, I am usually prepared for them. I am the queen of organization, and can find anything within seconds- thanks to my label-maker!
However, I also believe we all need balance. I am really conscious of the fact that I have to work hard not to let my Judging preference run my life. Thankfully, my partner has strong Perceiving preferences. It took many years of learning to appreciate our differences, but now I rely on him to balance my J-ness! I used to think he was trying to make me crazy. In my mind, if I am supposed to be somewhere at 10:00, then I think I am late if I arrive after 9:45. Whereas my partner thinks 10:00 is more of a suggestion- arriving anytime between 10:00 and 11:00 is in the range of acceptability. As a result, we are often late in spite of my preferences.
When he does the dishes he typically leaves one pan in the sink, where I don't believe the job is done until every last dish is in the cabinet (and the sink is cleaned...and the counter is wiped off...etc, etc).
We also differ in our beliefs about when working and playing take priority. I have always tried to live by the "Work Hard, Play Hard" philosophy (one of my dad's famous phrases), however I also live by "You cannot play hard until you've worked hard" philosophy. My partner can alternate between work and play on a minute-by-minute basis. In the early years of our relationship, this caused considerable conflict. When we would be cleaning the house, he would get distracted easily. While I was cleaning, I'd look in our office and see him sitting at the computer. I would get furious that I was the only one working, and he would calmly explain that he was just downloading music to iTunes so we could have "cleaning" music playing in the background. I was convinced this was just one more way for him to avoid working, but in reality, he thought he was facilitating a positive work experience.
While I will never be able to have his level of spontaneity, acceptance of change, or appreciation for open-ended plans, I am grateful for the balance he brings to the relationship. It takes a lot of effort to reserve my Judging preference. I have to actively think to myself "Is this a critical issue? Do I need to be upset that we are not on my schedule? Do we really need to plan this out this thoroughly?" It is uncomfortable for me, but I actively choose my battles now by knowing that my extreme J preference is not always a positive aspect of our relationship. I still feel internal stress when I believe we are showing up late, but I stop and literally ask myself "Is this a critical moment?" and typically I calm myself down and go with the moment (as much as a strong J can).
I'd love to hear from other individuals with a strong Judging preference. Do these stories resonate with you? Please share your own experience. Or, are you a P who is in a relationship with a J? How do you both compromise?